If you are a beginner, lessons are usually the best way to start, unless you have lots of pals who surf who can teach you. Go to a real surf shop. The folks there can hook you up with lessons, and even rent you a board to learn on. Don't rush into buying anything, until you have had a few lessons and decide that surfing is really something you want to stick with. Please don't waste your money buying something on line. When you are ready to buy, rent or borrow a variety of different style boards to see what suits you best. Try before you buy, a surfboard is a big investment.
Maybe a gift certificate for some lessons and board rental would make a better birthday gift that a board that may not be the right one for you. Bics are junk popouts, but I will say this for them, they are incredibly durable, and they are not made in sweat shops in China. But, I still don't recoomend any popouts, ever. There are way too many decent boards on the market.
There is still no 'one size fits all' answer. Before anybody could even come close to suggesting a board for you, your weight, skill level, local wave conditions and how much you can afford to spend are all factors to be considered.
Be careful of what you read here on line. There are lots of really well meaning young folks who have neat answers about surfing, but at 56, I tend to classify anyone under 25 as a kid. After I found this site, I figured that I could answer a few questions, and spread the 'good news' of surfing. After you master the ocean, get your REAL advice from a surf shop, where industry professionals earn their rent money selling surfboards. However, if they think you are just a 'kook' tourist out to rent a board, you won't necessarily get the best attention.
There are way too many people who "surf' who have zero water skills, and are dangerous to themselves and other surfers. I see at least one or two every time I surf at a crowded break. Don't join their ranks. If you want to surf. do it right.
Most people learn best on long boards, although I have seen lots of surfers start on a short board and master it. In the long run, there are NO RULES on what type of board you have to learn on. Long boards are ideal for learners. There are also good intermediate length boards to learn on, funshapes, mini-mals and some hybrids. So, as you see there are a lot of choices out there, and lot depends on what your skill level is right now.
THE REAL BOTTOM LINE IS: Go to a Surf Shop, not a computer. The pros there can give you the right answers!!
Good luck. Once you try surfing (and learn the 'right way') you'll have fun for life. I have been surfing since 1966.
Take the time to check out the links, especially "No Popouts"
http://www.surfingforlife.com/history.ht...
http://www.mckevlins.com/nopopstory.htm
http://360guide.info/surfing/surfboard
Happy 21st Birthday!